Wednesday, May 22, 2013

Controvertial Questions


Is it fair to protect other species from death by killing this one? 
If they are well controlled, can they improve Colombia's environment?


23 comments:

  1. Is it fair to protect other species from death by killing this one?
    - Yes, because this frog is causing a lot of death, so if you kill it, many living organisms would survive.

    If they are well controlled, can they improve Colombia's environment?
    - No, because they cause a lot of deaths.

    ReplyDelete
  2. This comment has been removed by the author.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. The population should not be completely extermined but I agree with controling the population because as it has no predator they can damage the equilibrium of the ecosystem and even end with other species that are found on the environment.
      -Isabel Cardenas-

      Delete
  3. This comment has been removed by the author.

    ReplyDelete
  4. It is fair to kill this animal to control other species, because if we let this specie reproduce and to get bigger everyday it is only going to finish with other ones.

    there is one form to control this specie without killing it, and that is if we bring its depredator, but is the risk that this depredator kills other native species and the problem just gets bigger and bigger.

    ----
    the info is complete, and there is a good organization. the images could be bigger in order for us to see better the animal.

    ReplyDelete
  5. Is it fair to protect other species from death by killing this one?
    - I think it is not fair, but if the frogs have a native place (US)where they don´t need to be killed, the ones that are here could be killed, without "dissappearing" the species.

    If they are well controlled, can they improve Colombia's environment?
    - Yes, because the species threatened by extinction thanks to that frog could be able to reproduce and be safe now.

    ReplyDelete
  6. The specie shouldn't be exterminated but controlled because if not many species may die just for one, which instead of helping the environment they threaten it. Also, as it has no predator it reproduces very fast and the danger increases for the other species.

    ReplyDelete
  7. It is fair because this animal is changing the food chain and killing other animals. This frog is an invasive animal so it is affecting an environment.
    They are very difficult to control, but if they could be controlled, the Colombia's enviornment would improve.

    ReplyDelete
  8. it is not fair to kill them but they have to be controlled so that they dont threatened other species.
    they do not belong to colombias environment because they produce more damages than benefits.
    -manuela ochoa

    ReplyDelete
  9. It is fair because this specie is killing many other species and it is better to protect many species that only one, also this specie is affecting and changing the food chain.
    If they dont have any pradator its difficult to control the effects that this specie is causing in the food chain.

    ReplyDelete
  10. 1. yes because this species is killing others and to protect others we have to kill this one, it doesnt matter if we kill them here because their specie has other organisms in their native enviorment, killing all their organisms here will help other species survive without making this Rana Toro be extint.

    ReplyDelete
  11. It is fair to kill this specie in Colombia (which it isn´t their native habitat) because it is causing the death of Colombia´s native species. If we don´t kill it, it will kill our species, and our biodiversity would be reduced in a significant way.

    If they aare well controled they couldn´t improve Colombia´s environment or biodiversity because its nautre behavior is to compete for territory. And how do they comete for territory, they kill other species.

    ---------

    The organization of the blog is good, but it could improve. In my opinion citation sholdn´t go at the begining of a document, but at the end.

    Images could be biger to see the animal in a better way.

    ReplyDelete
  12. Is it fair to protect other species from death by killing this one?
    -yes it is fair because we would protect many species of different types, and killing this specie it only envolves 1 specie, not many.

    If they are well controlled, can they improve Colombia's environment?
    - the specie would be difficult to control and i dont think it will improve Colombias enviornment, it would iimprove the "quantity" of species but in general the enviornment no.

    Juliana Trespalacios

    ReplyDelete
  13. Is it fair to protect other species from death by killing this one?
    - I think that there are more ways of controlling this species rather than killing this animal, there can be more ways like controlling and regulating this specie reproduction

    If they are well controlled, can they improve Colombia's environment?
    - I think that the enviorment could improve if this specie is controlled, but there are more factors that also damage the enviorment that must be taken into account, like other animals that also cause damage.

    ReplyDelete
  14. I think we should start a process for killing or capturing them until they are extint in this region to protect the species that are being afected by this invasive species

    ReplyDelete
  15. I think it is fair to kill this species because we save more, however, this frog may not be threatening in another environment so in conclusion i think it is fair but just if it's doing something wrong to the ecosystem like in colombia.

    -Laura Castro-

    ReplyDelete
  16. It is fair to kill this species to protect the other organism that are affected by this invasive species. In addition the species should be killed or controlled in order to keep the balance in the ecosystem.

    A new idea could be to create a campaign of hunting the species in the areas where it was introduced and where it is damaging the environment.

    The blog is organized, nonetheless there are many spelling mistakes and syntax mistakes that should be corrected to make the blog more serious. The images and the design are very good

    ReplyDelete
  17. I think that is not fair because we can regulate it with certain policies that would help the other organisms survive. Also I do not think that if it is well regulated, it could improve the environment because the environment would have other factors which could damage the environment. I think that the Government should isolate it from the others species. The blog has good information, good images, and it is complete and organize.

    ReplyDelete
  18. I think is fair to kill these animals to protect other species, if we doesnt stop these frogs know, in a future, the affected animals will be endager.

    Other solution could be to separate a special hábitat where this animals can reprduce and have food without affecting others.

    In generak your blog is very complete. It has all the information and the information is very complete, organized and clear.

    ReplyDelete
  19. I think is fair to kill this animal becuase this animal is killing other native frog and fish.Also he doesnt have predators this mean that in a certain amount of time the frog will be increase of population and more expanse in area becuase he adapt good to other climate.Also it affects the food chain.

    ReplyDelete
  20. The blog is compete and organize.Be carefull with the grammar mistakes.

    ReplyDelete
  21. I think that the killing iif the species is not an issue of fairness. I think that the rana toro should be controled so that the other species can live, without killing the rana toro in a total way.
    -Alejandra B

    ReplyDelete
  22. we have to kill this specie to protect other. The blog is very good

    ReplyDelete